top of page
  • Writer's pictureRealFacts Editorial Team

The Death Knell Is Tolling For Family Sit-Down Restaurants: What's The Future For All Their Empty Husks?


The death knell is tolling for family sit-down restaurants, and their once-beloved dining spaces are increasingly becoming vacant husks across the American retail landscape. Earlier this month, nostalgia took a hit as nearly 100 Red Lobster locations shuttered following the company's Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing. This closure is part of a broader trend, with at least a dozen major casual dining chains planning to scale back their portfolios this year. For investors, the fallout presents a mixed bag of opportunities and challenges.

The Decline of Casual Dining Chains

Restaurants that dominated the U.S. dining scene in the 1980s and 1990s are struggling to adapt to rapidly evolving consumer demands. Red Lobster's bankruptcy filing is emblematic of this trend, with the chain suffering a $76 million revenue loss last year. A well-intentioned but ultimately disastrous decision to make its endless shrimp promotion a permanent menu item further exacerbated its financial woes, costing the company $11 million.

The pandemic accelerated the decline of many casual dining establishments. Labor shortages, rising ingredient costs, and declining foot traffic have led to closures nationwide. Red Lobster has seen guest visits plummet by 30% since 2019, while chains like Applebee's and TGI Friday's have also significantly reduced their footprints.

Real Estate Implications

As these restaurants close, they leave behind large, specialized spaces that are challenging to repurpose. The average Red Lobster location in Texas, for example, spans 7,400 square feet—considerably larger than the sub-2,500-square-foot spaces that today’s prospective tenants prefer. This mismatch complicates efforts to backfill these vacancies.

The real estate market's response will vary by region. In high-demand areas with low vacancy rates, such as Dallas-Fort Worth, these empty spaces could become prime real estate opportunities. Steve Triolet, senior vice president of research and market forecasting at Partners, notes that there is a shortage of second-generation restaurant spaces in DFW, which could make Red Lobster's locations highly sought after by new tenants.

In contrast, less desirable markets might struggle more with these vacancies. Older buildings with dated architectures can be difficult to adapt for new uses, particularly in an environment where high interest rates make renovations or demolitions costly.

Emerging Opportunities

Despite these challenges, the current market conditions present unique opportunities for savvy investors. With the closure of numerous casual dining chains, the landscape is ripe for innovation and adaptive reuse. Investors should consider several key strategies to capitalize on the evolving retail environment.

1. Embrace Adaptive Reuse: Given the unique footprints of former casual dining spaces, creative adaptive reuse can be a viable solution. For example, Velvet Taco, a Dallas-based brand, has successfully repurposed unconventional spaces, including a former sex shop in Houston. Investors can look for similarly innovative concepts that can breathe new life into these large, specialized spaces.

2. Target High-Demand Markets: In regions experiencing rapid population growth and low vacancy rates, such as Dallas-Fort Worth, the demand for restaurant spaces remains high. Investors should focus on these high-demand markets where second-generation restaurant spaces are scarce. This scarcity can drive competition among potential tenants, potentially leading to favorable leasing terms for landlords.

3. Consider Mixed-Use Development: In areas where large restaurant spaces are less desirable, mixed-use development can be a strategic approach. Partnering with developers to create spaces that combine retail, dining, and residential elements can attract a diverse range of tenants and increase the property's value. Mixed-use developments can also better align with the current consumer preference for integrated lifestyle experiences.

4. Monitor Market Trends: Investors should stay attuned to market trends and shifts in consumer behavior. The rise of fast-casual and quick-service restaurants, which require smaller footprints, indicates a shift in dining preferences. Understanding these trends can help investors identify emerging brands and concepts that are poised for growth and could be suitable tenants for vacant spaces.

5. Leverage Media Attention: The closure of prominent chains like Red Lobster has generated significant media attention. Investors can capitalize on this heightened awareness to attract interest in their properties. As Mike Pittman II from Cushman & Wakefield suggests, landlords in less competitive markets should seize the opportunity to market their spaces aggressively while they are in the spotlight.

6. Prepare for Market Timing: High interest rates have made new construction and extensive renovations more expensive. However, if interest rates begin to decline, there could be a surge in development activity. Investors should be prepared to act quickly to take advantage of more favorable economic conditions, potentially leading to a flood of new developments and adaptive reuse projects.

Navigating the Future

The current downturn in the casual dining sector presents both challenges and opportunities for investors. By embracing adaptive reuse, targeting high-demand markets, considering mixed-use developments, staying attuned to market trends, leveraging media attention, and preparing for changes in economic conditions, investors can navigate the evolving landscape effectively.

As the retail market continues to transform, the demise of legacy family sit-down restaurants opens the door for innovative concepts and adaptive reuse strategies. Investors who can adapt to these changes and identify new opportunities will be well-positioned to succeed in the dynamic retail real estate market.


bottom of page