Broadcom's Stock Decline: A Potential Buying Opportunity
Broadcom, one of the largest chip makers in the world and behind the scenes leader in AI, experienced a significant decline in its stock price following its third-quarter earnings report for fiscal 2024. The company’s stock fell by 10.4% Friday after announcing financial results that both surpassed and fell short of investor expectations. While Broadcom's overall performance was strong, the market reaction was primarily driven by concerns over its guidance for the fourth quarter, for non AI related segments within the company. The report as we will dive into may present a buying opportunity as the long-term future performance is very promising with a now average 1 year price target of $195. At the current price of $137 in one year that projects to a 42% increase in Brodcom’s stock price one year from today.
Solid Results Overshadowed by Slight Revenue Miss
In the third quarter, Broadcom reported revenues of $13.1 billion, narrowly surpassing analysts’ expectations of $12.98 billion. Adjusted earnings per share (EPS) came in at $1.24, slightly above the Wall Street consensus of $1.22. Despite this positive performance, the company’s stock experienced its worst post-earnings reaction in history, driven by a combination of factors that left investors unsatisfied.
A key reason for the decline was the company’s revenue guidance for the fourth quarter, which came in just below expectations. Broadcom forecasted $14 billion in revenue for Q4, marginally short of the $14.11 billion Wall Street had anticipated. In the current climate of high investor expectations for AI and tech companies, even small deviations from estimates can lead to sharp declines in stock prices.
Broadcom’s revenue growth in the quarter was heavily influenced by its acquisition of VMware in late 2023. Excluding VMware’s contributions, Broadcom’s organic revenue growth was a modest 4% year-over-year. While this reflects some underlying strength in its core businesses, the company is clearly leaning on the VMware acquisition to fuel growth.
AI-Driven Growth Powers Broadcom Semiconductor Segment
A major bright spot for Broadcom remains its AI-related products, which have driven much of its recent revenue growth. Broadcom's semiconductor segment, particularly in AI, saw strong performance, with AI-related revenues estimated to have contributed around 24% of total revenue. In Q3, the company’s AI-related revenue reached approximately $3.1 billion to $3.2 billion, and management expects this figure to grow to over $3.5 billion in the fourth quarter.
CEO Hock Tan highlighted this strength in AI demand, noting robust sales of Broadcom’s Ethernet networking products and custom AI chips. These chips are essential for accelerating the processing of AI workloads, a crucial need for companies developing AI applications. Broadcom’s networking revenue grew 43% year-over-year to $4 billion, with a significant portion driven by demand for AI-related networking and custom AI accelerators. Broadcom’s three key customers for custom AI chips include Meta Platforms (Facebook’s parent), Alphabet (Google’s parent), and now Open AI (maker of Chat-GPT) is working to produce a chip with them.
However, the strong performance in AI contrasts sharply with other segments of Broadcom's business. For instance, non-AI networking revenue dropped 41% year-over-year, although it showed sequential improvement of 17%. Other areas, such as server storage connectivity and the wireless and broadband markets, also faced challenges, with some segments experiencing year-over-year declines as steep as 49%.
Market and Macroeconomic Factors Weigh In
In addition to the concerns over Broadcom’s guidance, broader market dynamics also contributed to the stock's drop. Major indices fell sharply on the same day due to a weaker-than-expected August jobs report, which stoked fears about the broader economic outlook. In this environment, even companies like Broadcom, which posted solid earnings, are not immune to macroeconomic headwinds.
Moreover, investor sentiment towards AI stocks has become increasingly cautious. After a significant run-up in valuations for AI-related companies, investors are demanding more than just marginal earnings beats—they want companies to significantly exceed expectations to justify high stock prices. Broadcom’s slight outperformance on the top and bottom lines was not enough to offset the disappointment over its Q4 guidance, particularly in a market environment where expectations are sky-high for AI-related firms.
Strong Financials and Cash Flow
Despite the stock’s sharp decline, Broadcom’s underlying financials remain strong. The company generated $4.96 billion in cash from operations during the quarter, a 5% increase from the same period last year. Free cash flow (FCF) came in at $4.79 billion, representing 37% of total revenue. Excluding restructuring costs and the integration of VMware, free cash flow rose 14% year-over-year to $5.3 billion.
Broadcom ended the quarter with $10 billion in cash and cash equivalents, up slightly from the previous quarter. However, the company’s debt levels remain high, with $66.8 billion in long-term debt, largely a result of its acquisition strategy. While Broadcom’s free cash flow generation remains robust, the company will need to continue balancing its debt load with growth initiatives and shareholder returns. The company has a net debt to equity ratio of 91.4% which is a concern but almost all of those debts are in the long term and are projects for the future of the company.
AI Growth Opportunities Amid Non-AI Challenges
Looking ahead, Broadcom faces both opportunities and challenges. On the positive side, AI demand continues to drive the company’s growth, particularly in its semiconductor business. The company has raised its full-year AI revenue forecast to $12 billion, up from the previous estimate of $11 billion. Additionally, management expects fourth-quarter revenue growth of 51% year-over-year, driven largely by AI and its acquisition of VMware.
However, Broadcom’s non-AI business remains a concern, with several key markets, such as broadband and industrial, showing significant year-over-year declines. While some of these areas may have bottomed out, it remains to be seen whether they can recover meaningfully in the coming quarters.
Broadcom’s success in the AI space also faces potential competition. While the company remains a key supplier of custom AI chips and networking equipment for hyperscale data centers, it must contend with the possibility that its customers, such as Google and Meta, could increasingly design their own chips in-house. Moreover, Nvidia, the current leader in AI semiconductors, could also enter the custom chip space, further intensifying competition.
AI Strength Meets Non-AI Challenges
Broadcom’s Q3 results present a mixed picture. On one hand, the company continues to benefit from strong demand for its AI-related products, which are driving significant revenue growth. On the other hand, its non-AI businesses remain challenged, and investors were disappointed by the company’s slightly lower-than-expected Q4 guidance. While Broadcom remains well-positioned in the AI market, it faces ongoing challenges in maintaining growth across its entire portfolio. Investors will be closely watching how the company navigates these challenges in the coming quarters.
Comments